By Noah Ploff
This evening, the Washington Commanders take on the New York Giants at MetLife Stadium on Thursday Night Football.
The last time these two teams met was in Week 5, when the game ended in a tie. The game went to overtime, where the defense got a stop for the Commanders, and the offense drove down the field well into field goal range. With no timeouts left and time ticking down, quarterback Jayden Daniels went down on a broken play and didn’t get the ball snapped quickly enough. Just like that, instead of what should have been a win for the Commanders, the game ended in a 27-27 tie.
Giants injuries and defense
The Giants come into the game with a 5-2-1 record and as 2.5-point favorites. Last week against the Eagles, starting quarterback JJ McCarthy suffered a hip injury on a hard hit from Eagles linebacker Zack Baun. McCarthy has no injury designation for the game against the Commanders and is a full go, despite some possible discomfort.
Starting running back Cam Skattebo missed last week’s game against the Eagles due to a hamstring injury he suffered against the Texans in Week 7. He also had a solid week of practice and is good to go for the game tonight.
The Giants' defense has been one of the best in the league against the pass, ranking third in passing yards allowed per game. They are also top five in total yards allowed per game. One of the biggest defensive issues for the Giants, however, has been sacks and pressure on the quarterback. Going into the Eagles game, the Giants only had 11 sacks on the season. They made that a point of emphasis against Tanner McKee last week, as they totaled five sacks in the game, which has them ranked 24th in sacks now. Washington’s offensive line has had several injuries and struggled all year when it comes to pass protection, so expect the Giants to bring pressure.
Commanders struggles and injuries
The Commanders enter this Thursday night matchup with a record of 2-5-1. Injuries and awful end-of-game decision-making have been the headlines of this disappointing season. Daniels re-dislocated his elbow in Week 2 just before halftime against the Dallas Cowboys, which put him out for two weeks. Star wide receiver Terry McLaurin tore his patellar tendon against the 49ers and is out for the season. Multiple-time All-Star left tackle Laremy Tunsil tore his triceps in practice and is out for the season. Those are just a few of the injuries that have plagued the Commanders.
The bad decision-making at the end of games is another thing. In their season opener against the Eagles, the Commanders had a chance to tie the game with a two-point conversion. Offensive coordinator David Blough called a shovel pass to a backup tight end. The play was easily stopped, and the Commanders would lose. The most notable of all of these mishaps happened the last time the Commanders played the Giants, when the game clock wound down to zero with Washington well within field goal range.
Commanders offensive keys
The main point of focus for the Commanders tonight is going to be whether they can play a clean game and come away with a solid win. Even with McLaurin out hurt, there are many other weapons, including veteran receiver Stefon Diggs, tight end Chig Okonkwo, and rookie receiver Antonio Williams. Beyond all of those players is the greatest weapon for the Commanders: their franchise quarterback, Jayden Daniels. In his rookie season, we saw what he is capable of, and they just haven’t been able to tap into his versatility enough yet this season. Daniels has had several good passing games, but in these past few games, he hasn’t been using his legs as much. His legs are what make him a dual-threat quarterback, and I’d look for the Commanders to draw up some designed runs for him tonight and have him use his legs a little more freely.
In order for Daniels to have time to run as well as throw, he is going to need his offensive line to perform better. Daniels ranks near the bottom of the league in average time in the pocket, with 1.8 seconds. For some reference, Drake Maye, who is another member of the 2024 draft class, leads the NFL in this category with an average of 2.7 seconds. Another member of the same class, Caleb Williams, isn’t far behind with an average of 2.5 seconds. When you compare the stats, you see just how poorly the Commanders' offensive line has performed this season. Nick Allegretti, who was the starting center at the start of the season and got benched, is going to have to step up with Lucas Patrick out of the game in concussion protocol.
Washington defensive keys
If Washington wants to win tonight, they’re also going to need their defense to step up in a big way. They started off the season slowly, giving up 24+ points in each of their first five games, but since then have given up 23, 10, and 20. They are steadily improving in pass defense with the help of Trey Amos being back and healthy, and they have been solid all season against the run. The position that has hurt the Commanders the most has been tight ends. Last time they played the Giants, Isaiah Likely had a career game, posting 11 catches for 94 yards and two touchdowns. Malik Nabers, who is arguably a top-10 receiver in the NFL, also had a monster game with 11 catches for 121 yards and a touchdown. Washington is going to need to shut down these two if they want to win.
No matter what the analysts and stats say, we look to be in for an entertaining NFC East matchup. My score prediction for the game is 24-21 Commanders.